User testing best practices

Learn how to design effective user tests that deliver actionable insights. From choosing the right task types to recruiting participants, this guide covers everything you need to run successful research.

Test design guidelines

Keep tests focused

The sweet spot is 5-10 tasks per test. Longer tests lead to fatigue, lower completion rates, and rushed responses toward the end.

If you have more questions, consider splitting into multiple focused tests.

The 5-user rule

Research shows that 5 users find ~85% of usability issues. Start small, iterate, and test again—rather than one large test.

Source: Nielsen Norman Group research on usability testing sample sizes.

Write clear prompts

Be specific about what you're asking. “What do you think?” is vague. “How easy was it to find the search function?” gets better responses.

Specific questions lead to actionable feedback you can act on.

Don't lead the witness

Avoid biased language like “How much did you love...” Instead, use neutral phrasing: “What was your experience with...”

Neutral questions get honest feedback, not the answers users think you want.

Participant guidelines

Recruit the right people

The best feedback comes from people who match your target audience. Use screener questions to filter participants based on demographics, experience level, or job role. Testing with the wrong users leads to misleading insights.

Set clear expectations

Your welcome message should explain what participants are testing and roughly how long it will take. When people know what to expect, they engage more thoughtfully and complete tests at higher rates.

Quality over quantity

5 thoughtful responses beat 50 rushed ones. Focus on recruiting engaged participants rather than maximizing numbers. Our AI analysis works best with detailed, honest feedback.

Task types and when to use them

Each task type is designed for specific research goals. Choose the right one to get the most useful feedback.

Likert scale

Collect quantitative ratings on a scale. Perfect for measuring satisfaction, agreement, or preference levels.

Best for:

  • Measuring satisfaction or sentiment
  • Tracking metrics over time
  • Comparing before/after results

Tip: Enable 'Share your feedback' to understand the reasoning behind ratings.

Qualitative

Gather open-ended text responses. Ideal for detailed feedback, explanations, and suggestions.

Best for:

  • Understanding the 'why' behind behavior
  • Collecting ideas and suggestions
  • Exploring first impressions

Tip: Ask one clear question at a time for the best responses.

A/B Images

Show two images side-by-side for comparison. Perfect for A/B testing designs, layouts, or visual options.

Best for:

  • Comparing design iterations
  • Testing logo or branding options
  • Making visual preference decisions

Tip: Use similar image sizes and quality for fair comparison.

A/B Video

Display two videos for comparison. Ideal for testing animations, demos, or different content approaches.

Best for:

  • Comparing animation or motion styles
  • Testing video content variations
  • Evaluating different demos

Tip: Keep videos similar in length for balanced comparison.

Figma

Link to interactive Figma prototypes. Great for testing user flows and interactions before development.

Best for:

  • Validating designs before building
  • Testing navigation and user flows
  • Getting feedback on interactive elements

Tip: Set your Figma prototype to 'anyone with link can view' for testers to access it.

Website

Direct users to test an external website. Perfect for usability testing of live sites.

Best for:

  • Testing live product usability
  • Conducting competitor analysis
  • Evaluating landing pages

Tip: Provide specific tasks like 'Find the pricing page' for focused feedback.

Video

Embed videos for participants to watch. Great for gathering feedback on video content, demos, or tutorials.

Best for:

  • Testing tutorial or training videos
  • Evaluating advertisements
  • Getting feedback on product demos

Tip: Tell participants what to focus on before they watch.

Target

Ask participants to click on specific areas of an image. Excellent for testing visual hierarchy and attention.

Best for:

  • Testing CTA placement and visibility
  • Understanding where users look first
  • Validating visual hierarchy

Tip: Use clean, uncluttered images for clearer click data.

Quick decision guide

If you need...Use this task type
Numbers/ratings to measure somethingLikert scale
Detailed written explanationsQualitative
To compare two imagesA/B Images
To compare two videosA/B Video
To test an interactive prototypeFigma
To test a live websiteWebsite
Feedback on video contentVideo
To see where users click on an imageTarget

Ready to create your first test?

Put these best practices into action and start gathering meaningful user insights.

© 2025 Visiting Media. All Rights Reserved.